Whether you’re a landlord or a property manager, finding the right tenant is crucial for safeguarding your rental property. All tenants should be thoroughly vetted to ensure they’re financially stable and responsible. While credit reports are very helpful in determining a potential tenant’s financial obligations and payment history with creditors, they provide only a limited view of their overall financial health and suitability as a tenant.
Here are six reasons why a credit report alone isn’t enough when evaluating an applicant for tenancy:
- Limited Financial Picture
A credit report fails to offer a complete snapshot of an applicant’s financial situation. For example, they don’t show the applicant’s current income, savings, or assets, which are crucial for assessing their ability to afford rent. Relying solely on a credit score might lead to misjudging whether an applicant can afford the rent.
To get a clearer financial picture, you should request additional screening reports, as well as pay stubs, bank statements, or tax returns to complement the credit report. This will help you assess both past credit behavior and the applicant’s present financial health for meeting rental obligations.
- Absence of Rental Payment History
While credit reports offer a glimpse into an individual’s financial responsibilities and credit usage, they mainly focus on credit card payments, loans, and debts to creditors. Unfortunately, they often omit specifics about rental payments unless a tenant has experienced severe delinquencies leading to collections or legal actions—which aren’t common scenarios for most renters. Despite a seemingly impeccable credit score, a tenant could have a history of routinely paying their rent late or skipping out on rent entirely.
Rental payment history provides direct insights into an applicant’s behavior as a tenant. It showcases their consistency, responsibility, and reliability in meeting one of their most significant financial commitments: paying rent on time. Without this information, you may unknowingly accept tenants with past payment issues, which could potentially lead to inconsistent payments or other disputes in the future.
To gain insights into an applicant’s rental payment behavior, you should have a tenant verification performed. TSCI will contact the applicant’s previous landlords on your behalf to find out if there were any late payments, bounced checks, balances owed, complaints on file, legal notices, and more. With firsthand information about the tenant’s payment history and care of the property, you’ll have a better idea of what it would be like to rent to them.
- Potential Errors and Inaccuracies
Credit reports, while valuable, are not infallible. They can contain errors or inaccuracies that might significantly impact an applicant’s perceived financial standing, such as incorrect reporting by creditors, identity theft, or clerical errors. For example, a missed payment wrongly recorded on a credit report might not reflect the actual payment history of an otherwise punctual tenant.
Although tenants can dispute errors in their credit reports, these inaccuracies can often go unnoticed unless the applicant is actively monitoring their credit score. Additionally, correcting errors can take weeks or even months to resolve.
To mitigate these errors, it’s important to be aware of the limitations of credit reports and to cross-reference the information on them with other financial documents and screenings. Taking a more comprehensive approach will give you a more accurate portrayal of the applicant’s financial situation.
- Lack of Context
Credit scores are important metrics, but they don’t explain the “why” behind an applicant’s financial situation. A credit score might suddenly drop or rise due to various factors (like taking on a new loan or closing an old account) that are completely unrelated to an applicant’s ability to pay rent. Situations like medical emergencies, job changes, divorce, or family responsibilities might impact credit scores temporarily. Without context, you may misjudge their financial stability and overlook an otherwise suitable applicant.
In addition, recent improvements in an applicant’s creditworthiness may not be immediately visible in a credit report. To gain a better understanding of the factors beyond the credit score, you may want to consider asking the applicant about any recent life or financial changes or ask them to provide documentation that adds context.
- Missing Information
Credit checks overlook essential information covered in other screening reports that should also be considered during the screening process, such as:
- Background checks verify an applicant’s identity and may reveal potential legal issues.
- Rental history provides valuable information about an applicant’s past behavior as a tenant, including rental payments, care for the property, and any issues with previous landlords.
- Contacting previous landlords or personal references allows you to gather firsthand accounts of an applicant’s conduct, reliability, and character as a tenant.
- Criminal background checks uncover any records of criminal activity that might pose a risk to the property or other tenants.
- Employment verification ensuresthe applicant has a stable source of income to afford rent payments consistently.
- Eviction records can reveal whether an applicant has been previously evicted.
When used together, these reports provide a more comprehensive understanding of an applicant’s reliability, responsibility, and suitability. They offer a broader perspective beyond financial aspects and credit scores, so you can make the most informed decisions when selecting tenants.
- Risk of Overlooking Red Flags
Since they’re limited in scope and focus on financial history and creditworthiness, relying solely on credit checks might lead to missing warning signs or red flags, such as past property damage, legal disputes, disruptive behavior, conflicts with neighbors, or problematic interactions with previous landlords.
Protect Your Properties with Comprehensive Tenant Screening
Ultimately, while credit reports offer valuable insights, they represent only a fragment of a potential tenant’s overall profile. To conduct a more comprehensive evaluation, landlords should adopt a holistic approach to tenant screening. This includes conducting thorough background checks, rental history verification, cross-referencing references, employment validation, and even criminal background checks where legally permissible.
Tenant Screening Services (TSCI) has been a trusted partner for landlords and property managers seeking reliable tenants since 1985. We offer comprehensive tenant screening reports and many of the costs of our services can be deferred to the applicant. Our nationwide presence and adherence to the latest regulations guarantee compliance with all legal aspects of tenant screening. We prioritize accuracy, reliability, and adherence to regulatory standards to provide landlords with dependable and legally compliant information for their decision-making process. Our team offers full customer support whether you’d like a walkthrough of your screening report or have an issue with some of the data provided.
To find the best screening services for your needs, contact us today to book a consultation.
Landlords Property Managers Contact TSCI